Get all your news in one place.
100's of premium titles.
One app.
Start reading
The Independent UK
The Independent UK
Casey Cooper-Fiske

The key challenges facing new BBC boss Matt Brittin: From Trump to public trust

Matt Brittin speaks to members of the media as he arrives for his first day at Broadcasting House in London - (Reuters)

Matt Brittin, the former Google executive, has stepped into his new role as the BBC’s director-general, inheriting a corporation grappling with a series of profound challenges.

His tenure begins at a tumultuous period, marked by a substantial lawsuit from Donald Trump and recent public outcry over a racial slur broadcast during the Bafta Film Awards.

Among the most pressing issues facing the 57-year-old is a 10 billion dollar (£7.5 billion) lawsuit initiated by Donald Trump. The legal action concerns an episode of the BBC documentary series Panorama, broadcast in 2024, which Mr Trump claims gave the impression he encouraged his supporters to storm the Capitol building in 2021 following his election loss to Joe Biden.

The BBC recently filed a motion to dismiss the Florida lawsuit, warning of the "chilling effect" such litigation would have on "robust reporting on public figures and events".

In its motion, the corporation cited case law, stating: "Early dismissal is favoured given the powerful interest in ensuring that free speech is not unduly burdened by the necessity of defending against expensive yet groundless litigation, which would constrict the breathing space needed to ensure robust reporting on public figures and events."

President Trump is suing the BBC (Chris Jackson/PA)

The BBC further argued: "All the more so when plaintiff (President Trump) is among the most powerful and high-profile individuals in the world, on whose activities the BBC reports every day. The chilling effect is clear."

Reasons for dismissal also included a "lack of personal jurisdiction" and a "failure to state a claim", alongside the argument that Mr Trump’s defamation claim should fail as he cannot demonstrate the corporation "purposefully aimed the documentary at Florida".

Following the lawsuit, BBC chairman Samir Shah apologised for an "error of judgment", acknowledging the 2024 documentary’s editing gave "the impression of a direct call for violent action". This incident also preceded the resignation of the previous director-general, Tim Davie.

Mr Brittin also takes the helm months after the BBC faced significant criticism for broadcasting a racial slur during its coverage of the Bafta Film Awards.

During the ceremony on February 22, campaigner John Davidson, who has Tourette’s, was heard shouting an involuntary verbal tic as Sinners stars Michael B Jordan and Delroy Lindo presented an award. Despite a two-hour broadcast delay, the slur was not edited out.

The Culture, Media and Sport Committee subsequently wrote to Mr Davie, "seeking an explanation" for the oversight. Mr Davie expressed the BBC’s "profound regrets", calling it "a genuine mistake" that "should never have been broadcast".

Mr Davidson himself told US entertainment magazine Variety that the BBC "should have worked harder" to prevent the broadcast, adding he "had an expectation that the BBC would physically control the sound" at the event.

Michael B Jordan suffered a racial slur while presenting a Bafta award (Lucy North/PA)

This followed another editing controversy involving the BBC’s livestream of punk duo Bob Vylan leading chants of "death, death to the IDF (Israel Defence Forces)" at last year’s Glastonbury Festival.

The corporation’s funding model is another critical area for Mr Brittin. The BBC has declared its current system "not sustainable and needs reform", indicating a willingness to "consider radical options for future funding" in response to a government consultation.

While 94 per cent of adults use BBC output monthly, only 80 per cent pay the licence fee. The annual charge is set to increase to £180 from £174.50 from April 1, yet the BBC has suggested it would be open to a licence fee cut or more concessions to improve affordability.

Currently, three concessions are funded by the licence fee: free TV licences for over-75s receiving pension credit, half-price licences for the severely sight impaired, and an annual £7.50 fee for residents in certain care settings.

The BBC has consistently opposed a subscription model, warning it would create "a very different BBC" that would "not be universal", and has also appeared to rule out introducing advertising on its channels.

The BBC World Service, jointly funded by the licence fee and the Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, has seen its total budget decrease by 21 per cent in real terms between 2021 and 2026, primarily due to reductions in licence fee contributions.

A Public Accounts Committee (PAC) inquiry concluded earlier this month that the World Service risks losing its status as the most-trusted international broadcaster due to its inability to present a strong case for investment.

Despite reaching an average weekly audience of 313 million across 43 languages, the PAC highlighted a serious risk of losing ground to rivals, particularly given the £6 billion to £8 billion annually invested in global media operations by states such as Russia and China.

In March, Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper announced an additional £33 million in funding for the World Service over the next three years.

Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper announced funding for the BBC World Service (Stefan Rousseau/PA)

Finally, Mr Brittin faces the challenge of rebuilding public trust. His predecessor, Tim Davie, acknowledged a "full-on crisis" in public trust in institutions, admitting the BBC has made "serious mistakes, which we regret".

Mr Davie told the Rest Is Entertainment podcast: "We have a crisis. It is – we should call it – a full-on crisis that people do not trust too many of our institutions." He added: "Trust is built by people absolutely believing that someone is acting in their interest and that they listen to them."

Regaining this trust from sections of the public who have disengaged from the BBC will be a central task for Mr Brittin.

Sign up to read this article
Read news from 100's of titles, curated specifically for you.
Already a member? Sign in here
Related Stories
Top stories on inkl right now
One subscription that gives you access to news from hundreds of sites
Already a member? Sign in here
Our Picks
Fourteen days free
Download the app
One app. One membership.
100+ trusted global sources.